Two Suggestions (Film Strip and Keystoning)

What features would you like to see in Pixelmator Photo?
User avatar

2020-03-07 17:11:08

Hey! Huge fan of the Pixelmator apps, have been using Pixelmator Pro since it came out and jumped on Pixelmator Photo ASAP as well. Both softwares by far have my favorite editing tools and UI's, not to mention the most modern use of ML I've seen in any consumer app, but there are two recommendations that apply to both Pixelmator Photo and Pixelmator Pro (and even a possible desktop Pixelmator Photo ) that I hope may be considered going forward.

The first suggestion I'll make is one I'd bet gets suggested often, and that's a film strip system for Pixelmator Photo. The film strip in lightroom is your batch of pre-processed photos in your collection, and it's a huge benefit as it means moving between photos doesn't require you to leave your current editing tools, and is basically instant as every image in your batch is pre-rendered and ready to be edited on. I don't have any great ideas on how to implement this into Pixelmator Pro as the new(-ish) tabs editing system is kinda close to it, but in Pixelmator Photo it could either be a menu on the opposite side to the level adjustments, or it could replace the presets strip at the bottom of the screen. I think this change would make editing many photos by hand on Pixelmator Photo way faster and make it an easier switch from Lightroom CC users.

My second suggestion is keystone geometry editing. As someone who does a lot of street and architectural photography, I may value this feature more than others, but in my opinion it's the strongest lens correction setting besides crop. Keystoning, in case that's not the term it's best known as, is a geometry editing system that has the user draw two straight lines on surfaces they'd like to be parallel, and the software runs an algorithm to take the perpendicular lines in the image and make them both either perfectly vertical or horizontal. (This first made an appearance in Photoshop but is present in lightroom.) This tool could fall under the crop settings in Pixelmator Photo, and under the Crop tool in Pro, and would give those who just want to straighten out lines the best and easiest method of doing so in a pinch.

In no way are either of these changes necessary, just two suggestions I think could get even more powerful tools in your software. Thanks for making the best photo editing apps ever!

- Samuel (P.S. Pixelmator Pro for iPad when ;D)
User avatar

2020-03-10 17:33:09

Hey Samuel, thanks for the requests! The filmstrip-style editor is definitely a cool idea, though it would require a quite different workflow to be created from the group up, so I wouldn't hold my breath... Though who knows.

As for keystone correction — there is a perspective correction feature that lets you adjust both vertical and horizontal perspective that seems quite similar to what you're looking for. Or am I misunderstanding something? There's a little more info about this here: http://help.pixelmator.com/pixelmator-photo/1.1.3/#710
User avatar

2020-03-10 17:55:49

I do understand the difference in workflow styles between what it is currently and a filmstrip, but it could be a cool option! Anything to make going between pictures faster in Pixelmator Photo could be great to make it the truly quickest way to edit photos on the go.

The vertical and horizontal perspective adjustments are similar to keystone correction, but an actual keystoning editing system doesn't leave any perspective changes to trial and error/eyeballing which lets users get the best possible perspective change. The current tools are usable, just not nearly as easy or exact as I think they could be. It's more of a QoL change than anything.

Thanks for even considering these ideas! Truly some of the best devs there are.